Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026Delhi 18°C · Mumbai 25°C · Kolkata 23°C · Chennai 27°C · Bengaluru 23°C · Lucknow 18°C
Independent news and guest opinion
for everyday India
Breaking
Legal

Shiv Sena Case: Supreme Court Asks Thackeray Side to Explain Dissent vs Defection

A bench led by CJI Surya Kant asked Kapil Sibal to spell out the difference between dissent and defection under the Tenth Schedule as the Thackeray–Shinde hearing continued.

Buildings inside the Supreme Court of India complex
Photo: Supreme Court of India, inside buildings 01.jpg by Pinakpani, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Supreme Court on Thursday asked the Uddhav Thackeray faction of the Shiv Sena to explain where the line falls between “dissent” within a party and “defection” under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution, as it continued hearing the long-running dispute between the Thackeray and Eknath Shinde groups.

A bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana is hearing two linked matters. Uddhav Thackeray has challenged the Election Commission of India’s decision to recognise the Shinde group as the real Shiv Sena and give it the party symbol. Sunil Prabhu has challenged the Maharashtra Speaker’s refusal to disqualify the MLAs of the Shinde faction under the anti-defection law.

Sibal’s case

Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, for the Thackeray side, argued that the intention of Shinde and the other breakaway MLAs to walk out of the alliance with the NCP and Congress could not be passed off as mere dissent. He relied on the Constitution Bench ruling in Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary and pointed out that the Shinde group later joined hands with NCP leader Ajit Pawar.

Sibal said both factions cannot be the Shiv Sena at the same time, and asked what the Thackeray group would be if Shinde’s side were the real party. Treating such a split as dissent, he argued, would put democracy at risk wherever coalitions govern. Asked which party he meant, he said it was the legislative party.

What the bench asked

The Chief Justice noted that the rebels say they are still members of the Shiv Sena and object only to the alliance, and said the real question is whether that stand is dissent within the party. He asked Sibal to set out, at the next hearing, what dissent and defection mean from his side’s point of view.

Justice Bagchi observed that the answer may depend on the kind of government involved. In a single-party government, he said, such conduct would plainly be defection, but the position is less clear in a coalition. The hearing will resume on Wednesday.

Case: Sunil Prabhu v. Eknath Shinde, SLP(C) No. 1644-1662/2024 and connected matter.

— Legal Desk

Featured image: Photo: Supreme Court of India, inside buildings 01.jpg by Pinakpani, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Sources

Share this story

Related

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *